Link to Carleton
Philosophy
Dr.Randal Marlin
Link to Student Technology Assistant Home
   

 

Home

Outline

Schedule of topics &
readings

Announcements

Links

Learning in
retirement

 

 

Schedule of Topics and Readings, PHIL 2900 Fall/Winter, 2011-12

Topics are not always confined exactly to the times allotted. Some take more time, others less than indicated. Updated comments will regularly appear in the Announcements section during the year and should consulted weekly. Additional readings from Web sites will occasionally be suggested, and some may be compulsory reading.

Note: Readings in the coursepack are referred to by item number. Check the table of contents to find the item. Where only the item number is given, read all of the item. (Note that some readings are on reserve. Try to plan ahead for these materials.) Bold typeface in the readings section indicates a hyperlink.

 

DATES
TOPIC
READINGS, VIDEOS
         

Sept. 12, 14

 

Intro & overview; remarks
on Orwell and Ellul

 

Marlin, Propaganda and the Ethics of Persuasion (PEP) 13-15, 23-34; Ellul, v-xviii and 3-32; Ward, 3-6 (rsv); Orwell, “Politics and the English Language,” (also on rsv)


Sept. 19, 21   Definition   PEP 15-23; coursepack: Stevenson #1, Allen #2; Jay Black in The Ellul Forum 12-18 (rsv)
         
Sept. 26, 28   Propaganda history; Aristotle to Napoleon   PEP 43-62. Additional on-line readings, TBA, may be added.
         

Oct. 3, 5


  World War I propaganda (mainly British)


 

PEP 62-76; Marlin, "The Art of Faking Credentials"; Neander & Marlin, "Media and Propaganda: The Northcliffe Press ..."


Oct. 10

  Class suspended
  Thanksgiving holiday

Oct. 12  

Military
indoctrination

  Film, Gwynne Dyer, "Anyone's Son Will Do"


Oct. 17, 19   Communist propaganda; Cold War propaganda  

Domenach #3; PEP 76-79; Ellul, 303-313;
Frances Saunders, The Cultural Cold War, 1-6 (rsv)


Oct. 24, 26

  Nazi propaganda
  PEP 80-88, Doob #4, Freifeld #5


Oct. 31

 

Ellul: characteristics of propaganda

  PEP 34-39; Ellul, 33-87; Marlin, in The Ellul Forum, 9-12 (rsv)
         

Nov.
2 , 7

  Rhetorical devices and political persuasion   PEP, 95-118; Whately #6; Shakespeare #7; Plato, Aristotle # 8; MacLean #9; Senate Minutes #10; Harrison & Marlin #11; George Lakoff, Berkeley News
         
Nov. 9, 14   Bias in science reporting: polls & statistics   PEP, 118-132; Marlin #12; Ward, 9-36 (rsv)
         
Nov. 16, 21   Propaganda analysis; case studies   Jowett & O’Donnell, Propaganda and Persuasion, Ch. 6 (rsv); Olasky #13, Brennan #14
         
Nov. 23
 

Lippmann and stereotypes
News & selectivity,

 

Lippmann #15; Halberstam #16; Bruce Wark, study of CBC Ipperwash coverage (optional, rsv)

         
Nov. 28, 30   News distortion and multiperspectvism;
Chomsky on news filters
 

Glasser, Cohen, Gans & Newman #17 through #20; Manufacturing Consent, Ch 1 (rsv); Also news item #21.

         

Dec. 5

  Chomskyan themes

 

Cynthia Boas, #22; video: "Outfoxed"; I.F. Stone film

 

 

Scheduled
Examination

  Date, time and location TBA
         
   
Second Term,
  January 4-April 5, 2012
         
WEEK
TOPIC
READINGS

Jan. 4
 
Ethics and Objectivity
 
Ward #23 (Invention of Journalism Ethics, Chapter 7)

 

       
Jan. 9, 11   Lying and Ethics; coloration of truth   PEP, 137-171; McGovern, #24
         
Jan. 16, 18  

Lying and the public good;lies by officials

  Mearsheimer, Why Leaders Lie
         

Jan. 23, 25

 

Advertising and ethics

 

PEP,175-185; coursepack, #25 through #32. Focus mainly on #27 and #29.

         
Jan. 30, Feb. 1


  Shaping perception: PR  

PEP, 185-200; Marlin, "Tea Party Propaganda Exposed," in PEN, page six, additional material TBA

Feb. 6, 8


  Free speech theory; Mill and classical arguments
 

PEP, 205-234; Mill, On Liberty (found on the Web, one copy on reserve. Focus on chapters 2 and 5)

Feb. 13, 15


  Hate propaganda
and control
 

PEP, 235-240, Sumner #33; Optional: Supreme Court of Canada, R v Keegstra (rsv)

Feb 15


 
Essays due 5 p.m.

 

Room 3A38 Paterson


Feb 20-25
 


Reading Week

 

 

         

Feb. 27, 29

 

Controls on advertising

 

PEP, 240-249; coursepack #26-30; additional material TBA

Mar. 5, 7   Controls on news media; self-censorship   PEP, 250-263; Kent Commission materials; Marlin, "Self-Censorship and the Media" (rsv)
         
Mar. 12, 14
 

Government information and propaganda


 

PEP, 263-277; coursepack #34-37; Additional reading TBA

Mar. 19, 21

  Indoctrination and education

 

Naomi Klein, No Logo, 87-105 (rsv)
Film: "Grierson"

         
Mar. 26, 28


  Democratic ideals, propaganda

  Ellul, 118-192; Charity #38
Apr. 2, 4   Propaganda, ideology, and the future with the Internet   PEP 283-306; Whitton & Larson #39, Ward, 317-331 (rsv); Ellul, 193-257 (optional)
Home | Outline | Schedule of Topics | Links | Philosophy Home | Carleton Home | STA Home

Web page creation and training done by Kathryn Apunen Washburn summer 2001.

link to Carleton Home Link to Carleton directories link to Campus Map Link to Contact Carleton Link to Carleton Index Page Link to Carleton Search